Showing posts with label USA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label USA. Show all posts

Friday, October 9, 2026

Oh, I Think I Was Raped

We have been hearing about the Cornell (University) 7 - the frat boys who gangraped a Jane Doe on Oct 19, 2024. 


There have been 2 points of view along gender lines. One group believing that it was awful that the fraternity boys took turn violating her for hours when she was intoxicated. Some guys even invited others to join in, as though she was an edible thing being distributed. This was pathetic animal behaviour.


The second group points out two things. 

A) That if women cannot take responsibility for having consented while drunk, how can men be responsible for violating a woman when they, men, were drunk? 

B) How is it that Jane Doe's testimony initially was that it was all consensual and she later (after being disinvited to a Halloween party by the fraternity) said that 90% of all that happened that night was non-consensual? What gives.. Read this.


Both views make sense. This post primarily addresses the second group. Why did Jane Doe's testimony change? 


I was thinking about the Bhopal gas tragedy that occurred a few decades ago in the central Indian city of Bhopal. Poisonous gas fumes leaked from the factory of Union Carbide, an American company, and killed thousands of people residing near the Carbide factory. 


India is a developing country. At that time about 40 years ago it was a poor country. Compensation for deaths at that time may have been of the order of about $1000 per person. Indians were used to a paltry sum as compensation unlike the amounts paid out in the USA.

When Indian government realized that the payout could be much larger than $1000 per person they left the initial baseline figure and caught on to a higher number that was, say, $1 million per dead person. 


Now let's ask the question. Initially India was asking for a small amount per casualty because that was the norm in India. But when perhaps a sister pointed out that there is a different legal remedy which India could be entitled to, did India say "Nah, we don't want that million dollars per death" or did India say "Yes, that's what we want. It's legal too".

Now, a question to the second group. If you were representing India in the Bhopal gas tragedy case against Union Carbide. What would you claim finally even if you initially were quite comfortable with a different (much smaller) number? 


Now tell me. What's wrong with Jane Doe's thoughts? If the legal system gives her a chance to say "No, I think it was not consensual because even if I may have said Yes initially, I said so in my drunken state and hence the YES doesn't count.


Continuing further, let's see if the same principle can apply in matrimonial / divorce cases in India.

in India where women claim to have faced domestic violence and demand alimony the same principle above could apply. If I, the wife, believe that I may have been subjected to violence and that I could be legally entitled to a large alimony, why would I settle for anything else?

Isn't the question "Was i subject to domestic violence?" similar to "Was I raped?". There is a lot of subjectivity in each question. And if the answer can be yes, then there can be a mighty payback at the end. Why wouldn't I try to claim it?


There are 2 beneficial outcomes.

1. You claim more benefits. Maybe you will get some bonus. 

2. You have added one more case to the list of abuses against your gender, caste etc. 

By doing this we have diluted the importance of the genuine cases. Even those might now seem made up.


Pointing out or accepting a plausible explanation that absolves / empowers / enriches you while destroying a perceived enemy seems like a great ploy and very rewarding emotionally. Read the stories given in additional reading below.


Additional reading: 

  1. https://vbala99.blogspot.com/2018/09/stockholm-syndrome.html - rape isn't about consent. It's about how you feel after the event.
  2. Dowry harrassment case filed by wife after allegedly murdering her husband. If you had a legal option to file dowry harrassment legally, why wouldn't you?
  3. And this. A couple was in a consensual relationship for 3 years. Later the man didn't marry her. She filed a rape case against her partner. If legally you are allowed to file such a case, why wouldn't you?
  4. Trump is better.- Just like people were pointed to Joe Biden for all the problems in their life, perhaps Jane Doe was pointed to the 7 man target in the last couple of years. 
  5. https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1DDTLtfsoc/: Is t app similar to Cornell 7 snap chat with the gender reversed?
  6. NYT - The message thread

Sunday, September 29, 2024

Whom Do We Trust

I came across this: APNews being the trusted source of news for half the world. 


And there is Truth Social which also is read and trusted by half of America, the Republicans. Truth Social is Trump's own Twitter like platform.

Are APNews and Truth Social at the same level and alike then? Imagine if the CEO of AP News and Trump were both invited to be felicitated for adhering to the highest standards of truth! 

I am reminded of a comedy scene in a Tamil movie where a beggar, waiting for some money from a vegetable shop owner, finds himself standing next to a police constable who has come to the shop for hafta ("wet his beak" in Mafia terms) - both of them being shooed away by the shop keeper who is busy attending to his paying customers!

Having half the world read your news or listen to you is hardly a great thing. Truth Social does that too. I wish APNews would try to differentiate itself from Truth social.

Sunday, November 13, 2022

What Putin, Xi Want

https://apnews.com/article/taiwan-biden-indonesia-united-states-xi-jinping-3decd48c4d2e01da0008d5148237b28d?utm_source=homepage&utm_medium=TopNews&utm_campaign=position_04


So un-Ayn Rand like. It's not money or business or economics only that drives the end result. It's "my country is great" emotion. Whether MAGA (Make America Great Again) or MACA / MARA (Make China / Russia great again)!


What are we doing while trying to make our country great again? Taiwan, Ukraine are being affected in trying to make our respective countries great. Sad, isn't it?


Norway, Holland, Belgium, UK, Spain, Portugal etc did the same thing few centuries back. Hitler did it 80 years back. 


I guess the same thing may happen in future as well. Lebensraum seems to be crucial for man as it was for animals.


If i can't become uber wealthy by myself, i choose to get married to an Ambani. If my country can't become rich, I take over other countries. If I can't get enough votes in an election, i say that the other guy's votes belong to me, as Trump did.

Saturday, October 15, 2022

Nikola Trump And Special Effects

Nikola Founder Trevor Milton Convicted of Securities Fraud https://www.wsj.com/articles/nikola-founder-trevor-milton-convicted-of-securities-fraud-11665779578


"Among the misrepresentations cited by prosecutors in the trial were Mr. Milton describing an undrivable prototype to a crowd as “fully-functioning” and saying that Nikola was producing hydrogen fuel at a cost of $4 per kilogram when it cost other companies much more. In fact, Nikola wasn’t producing any hydrogen fuel at all, prosecutors said.

Mr. Milton’s lawyers said the Nikola founder acted in good faith and argued that the government had cherry-picked portions of his public statements."


Is this cherry picking?


"It is a distortion to say that Trevor Milton intended to commit fraud,” defense attorney Mr. Mukasey said during his closing argument. He said Mr. Milton’s statements were supported by those around him and cheered on by his leadership team, adding that important facts about Nikola’s business were fully disclosed to investors.  It’s not a crime to use special effects in a commercial,” he said of the Nikola One video. “Otherwise the government would have to indict the Energizer Bunny.” "


What is the line between special effects and blatant lying? Matter of fact, is special effects ok when the purpose is to mislead? Put another way blatant lying can be euphemistically said to be special effects or "alternate reality" as we say in the context of Trump.


“If someone wanted to commit fraud,” he said, “they would do it behind closed doors.” 

This is exactly like what people say about Trump. If a person does something in the open then it cannot be a crime? Putin is conducting a war in Ukraine. And the whole world knows about it. There is no camouflage. So it's not a crime?


Sunday, August 14, 2022

Trump's Modus Operandi And America's Weakness

Trump Lawyer Told Justice Dept. That Classified Material Had Been Returned https://nyti.ms/3w1NTZk


It's not just that Trump lies.

  • His lawyer said to the govt that all sensitive documents had been returned.
  • He then said as president he had the right to convert sensitive documents to non sensitive. (Declassify at will.)
  • He told the press that FBI had probably planted evidence.


And the biggest issue is that the American legal system will allow Trump to say that he himself had no clue what was brought to his house and no clue what his lawyers said to the govt on his behalf and the legal system will want to prove beyond reasonable doubt that he intended to sell the sensitive documents to Russia China Iran North Korea. How can anyone prove it?


Just like he claims that he had no idea what his accounting firm submitted as data to various financial entities. Atleast the Indian income tax says that ignorance is no excuse. We are that much better than Americans.


Trump is narcissistic. He feels entitled. That's why he wanted to win the 2nd term badly. With the weight of the presidency working for him and with his ability to redefine what executive privilege meant he would literally have been King.


Additional reading:

Saturday, August 6, 2022

What A Hoax

Alex Jones Ordered to Pay Punitive Damages to Sandy Hook Parents: Alex Jones claimed that a shooting event was a hoax. And he was ordered to pay $40m as compensation or punitive damages to the people who were affected by the shooting.


And there is another guy who claimed, still claims, that 2020 election won by Biden is a hoax. When is he going to be given punitive damages?

Monday, July 18, 2022

Red = MAGA

 The nationalist fervor MAGA (make America great again) is perhaps linked or correlated to other conservative agenda (anti abortion, white supremacy, removal of gay rights, anti immigration and so on). 


I guess this means that if i espoused conservative agenda I could use euphemise and say I wanted America great again. And have a bunch of red (Republican) States support me

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

Gun Legislation

Where Senate Republicans Stand on Gun Legislation: Read the opinions of senators who declined or deflected. Michael D Crapo's answer was similar to India's opinion on Ukraine war wrt sanctions on Russia.

Popular Posts

Featured Post

Oh, I Think I Was Raped

We have been hearing about the Cornell (University) 7 - the frat boys who gangraped a Jane Doe on Oct 19, 2024.  There have been 2 points o...