Showing posts with label Analysis And Prediction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Analysis And Prediction. Show all posts

Thursday, May 29, 2025

Being In Someone's Shoes

I am back here after a long break. Many things happened in those years. I have changed a little i guess in those years. Maybe I will write about events that happened then.

Now let's come to today's post!

A friend of mine lost her family, consisting of her parents and a brother, one by one. She was the only earning member in her family. Some acquaintance of hers remarked to her (my friend's) employer that my friend had gone through a very difficult time and managed it pretty well. 


To this the boss responded that anyone in my friend's position could and would have done the same thing. And hence there was nothing remarkable in what my friend did. 


Probably true what the boss lady said. Anyone who went through the same circumstances as my friend perhaps would have done the same thing. And maybe what my friend did wasn't remarkable. 


Just as anyone in Sachin Tendulkar's shoes would have achieved what he did. Anyone in Mahatma Gandhi's shoes would have done what he did. Anyone in Bill Gates's or Jeff Bezos' shoes would have done exactly what they did 

No big deal. 


I have a question here for the boss. What is a big deal? 

Thursday, May 18, 2023

Beautiful Thought and Beautiful Emotion

I was thinking of the difference between a beautiful emotion and a beautiful thought.


This is a Beautiful jathi someone choreographed. Look how it is.


Now this is an Excel sheet i choreographed.



See how beautiful it is.

What is the learning here? 

An emotion is exceptional if it moves your heart. 

A thought is exceptional if it serves a purpose, solves a problem. The sheet above may be an Excel jathi but not a useful one.

An expression of emotion can be beautiful. A thought is never beautiful. That's not the purpose of a thought.

If a thought seems beautiful, it was actually an emotion.

A person strong in emotions can create beauty and elegance. A person strong in thought cannot.


Saturday, April 30, 2022

Rules Based

 A friend sent me this article: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/04/28/united-states-should-practice-the-rules-based-order-it-preaches/. She asked: Why are so many democracies unwilling to condemn Russia?



My response: "A much better way to frame the division in the world is between countries that believe in a rules-based international order and those that don’t. " From the same article. 


If Western democracies were  so rule bound as the author suggests why were UK USA etc in bed with Saudi, China and Russia all these years? Why was uk so cosy with Russian oligarchs until the Ukraine invasion? How did those oligarchs suddenly become persona non grata in Feb this year? 


Why are we still doing business with China or Saudi (despite what we know Saudi did to khashoggi)? 


Are we, Western democracies, so honorable really? Isn't survival the driving force really behind our actions? Do we think the western democracies were ignorant until Feb? 


Why this holier than thou attitude suddenly?


Tuesday, November 9, 2021

A Profile Description

She is very emotional.

Has a complete lack of understanding of personal responsibility in the context of cause and effect. 

Imagine someone raped me. I slapped him. And then explains what happened that he did such a thing to me. We discuss it. And then he questions me why I slapped him. And that's all he remembers of the event. Not what he did earlier. 

This is how she is. Doesn't take responsibility for her action at all.


A liar, emotionally manipulative. Isn't capable of generosity. In case of emergency, would want to make sure she doesn't get stressed. Hates stress to herself. Extremely poor sleeper. 


Is capable of moving from saying she loves someone to the point where she wants to sleep with someone else in the space of 5 minutes.


Emotionally manipulative enough to know how to guide someone to propose to her and get him to want to sleep with her - her lack of touch with reality would make her claim that the other person proposed all on his own. When she explained her plan to get intimate with her old flame it was eye opening. 


Nice enough that her kids are comfortable with her and like spending time with her. Has a bunch of friends and colleagues that she is in regular touch with.


Her emotional needs are insatiable. Likely pointing to NPD and or BPD while she jokingly referred to bipolar in herself. 


If someone has an emergency she would say she will be there. And she would mean it literally. She will be there. Not doing much, perhaps texting or otherwise keeping herself engaged in things not relevant to the emergency.


Can't be relied upon to be consistently dependable and organized. 


Is very bright and intuitive. 

She has a tendency to take key words out of a sentence and create a different meaning out of the sentence. 

For example, if someone said they disliked prostitutes taking money for sex she might interpret that to mean that the person called her a prostitute. 


Has a huge void inside her like an emotional black hole and she seeks to fill it. She needs a person who will live for her, whether she can or will reciprocate is something she really doesn't much care about. Dedication to any person or thing doesn't come easily to her.


The love she proclaims that she has for an adult is the love that a woman has for chocolate. Not the love that a mother has for a child.


While her knowledge of maths and numbers is fairly limited, a maths problem at the level of grade 5 may be difficult for her, she says she teaches her children (in class 9) maths. This is an example of how she misrepresents reality. The truth perhaps (a guess) is that she sits with them and keeps them company and suggests that the children read this book or call up that friend to solve the problem and makes tea for them. Most mothers do this. This is not teaching maths. 


Claims that she knows a language when she can understand it at best and hardly speak it. This claim wasn't made in jest.


She said that her husband complained to her that she wasn't all there with him ever. She acknowledged that this was so.

She is preoccupied with her own emotions. Even when with her so called ideal man she said she would be on dating site chatting up others.


While she claims she is a very good housewife and mother, my belief is she spends way too much time with her own activities. 


In short, a very high maintenance person. She is used to a very high class of living. A kind that she most likely cannot get with her own efforts. 


All the good things in her life have been provided for to her. Her best accomplishments would not be commensurate with what she has been given.

She is not much bound my normal sense of restraint. She stays in the marital home because of her needs for the comforts that it provides while disliking the provider. I am sure she thinks she is an equal to "the provider" because she is married to him and has borne his children.


She has a high sense of self worth, perhaps out of very high needs. She is likely to suck the life out of any adult who is close to her so much so that they may wish to have her leave soon. There is a good amount of arrogance - the casual use of words that put down others. 

While she asserts that people hurt her often and that she is a doormat, I think she hurts others much more often. 


She claims that in relationships she assumes the guilt whenever there is an issue. But she frequently blames the other party for the issues. Her behaviour, according to her, have not been the cause but then she says she assumes the guilt, giving herself a saintly aura.


She comes very close to a person having a personality disorder. She claims she never gets angry. She is capable of extremely intense emotions including anger.


Relationship with her ideal man is more of satisfying her own needs and would involve little of satisfying his. 


She is self centred, unempathetic, extremely needy, controlling. And constantly on an emotional rollercoaster.


A relevant article in this context: https://www.ckju.net/en/dossier/machiavellianism-what-it-how-recognize-and-cope-machiavellians

She is certainly not psychopathic. 


In summary, what she says doesn't seem authentic. Her words can't be taken at face value. 

She said she was raised in a very loving family lacking nothing that a child would want. 


Why then? What happened? How did she turn out this way? 




Additional reading:

https://vbala99.blogspot.com/2021/10/to-lizard-with-love.html

Thursday, July 29, 2021

Truth, Nothing But The Truth

Some people think of truth as binary. Either what a person x said did happen or didn't happen. Meaning of the event were recorded, the event would either prove x right. Or not.


But then there is another interpretation of truth. What I call the feminine or emotional interpretation.

If my emotions tell me something and if I say it aloud then I have been truthful from my point of view of EVEN IF A RECORDING OF THE EVENT MAY CONTRADICT WHAT I SAID.


That is amazing. An emotional person describes truth as something being in sync with their emotions. 


And what emotions tell us may not be corroborated by a recording. 


We are aware of a game children play. A child whispers to something to another child, who in turn whispers what he heard from the first child to another child and so on. Finally, what we hear from the last child is quite different from what the first child said. Why is this so? Is it not the same reason? That the emotions in children tamper with the truth. And the child interprets what he heard based on what his emotions tell him. 


Both kind of truths, the ones that are verifiable and those that aren't go under the same umbrella of "truth". 

Just like the word love means two entirely different things.

(https://vbala99.blogspot.com/2017/02/understanding-love.html)


So when someone promises to tell the truth and they genuinely believe they are telling the truth, what they say may not be true - to the extent that their emotions have played with the reality.


The more emotional one is, the more adulterated the truth is, more grey their statements are.


If you ask a person "did you do it?":

  • A less emotional person will reply Yes or No.
  • A more emotional person will start with an explanation leading ultimately to whether they did it or not. The explanation is a reflection of their emotional state.


Pop Quiz:

Is Donald Trump largely emotional or not?


Rich, no?

Can I Call You Tomorrow At 4PM

I thought such a request, as in the subject line, meant that the person has committed to call at 4. 


It turns out that the "can I call you?" for many people (P type, as in MBTI) is in fact about getting a right to call and not an obligation to call.


I always assumed that the question created an obligation.

It took me so many years to realise it's just a right.


A related anecdote:

A friend of mine wanted her brother to come to her place to get something done. She kept reminding him and then he asked her whether she would be home at 3PM. She confirmed. She was waiting from 2:45PM till 4PM for her brother. But he didn't turn up. When she called her brother and asked him what happened, he explained that HE had asked her whether SHE will be home at 3PM. He pointed out that he never told her he will come to her house at 3PM.

Another case of a right (to come) but no obligation (to come). My friend had interpreted her brother's question incorrectly.


So it makes sense to confirm whether someone is assuming an obligation or just a right when they say (or ask) something.


Additional reading 

https://vbala99.blogspot.com/2021/07/proposing-to-multiple-women.html


Saturday, July 24, 2021

Selling And Repurchasing

Effect of selling in a falling market and buying at a lower price:


Let's assume we have 500 units of an equity mutual fund (MF) scheme at a current NAV of Rs100 per unit that were purchased at an NAV of Rs70. Total purchase cost = Rs70*500 = Rs35,000


Now let's assume the market is falling and I am very tense. The NAV has fallen to Rs 90. I decide to sell all the units. Assume my holding is for less than a year, so short term capital gains (STCG) will be levied (@ 15%).

Exit load will be 1%. 


What I get is 

500 units* 90*99% = Rs44,550. 


My gains will be (44550-35000)

= Rs 9550


My STCG will be 9550*15%= Rs1433

Nett of taxes and exit load what I have is 44550-1433 = Rs 43117


Now let's assume the NAV falls to Rs 80 and I invest all my proceeds into the same scheme at that NAV.


I get 43117 / 80 = 539 units.

Note that earlier I had 500 units.


Now let's assume that the NAV rises later to Rs115 and I again sell all the units at this NAV.


My redemption will now give me 539*115*0.99 = Rs 61365


My short term gains are now 

61365 - 43117 = Rs 18248


My tax will be 15% * 18248 = Rs 2737

What I will have nett of tax is 

61365 - 2737 = Rs 58628


If on the other hand I had never redeemed inbetween and I had held on the 500 units of the equity scheme and sold it at NAV of Rs 115 (and assume this happened after a year so it's long term capital gains).


My proceeds will be 500*115 = 

Rs 57500. Note that there is no exit load because I sold after a year.


My gains = 57500 - 50000 = Rs7500


My tax will be max 10%= Rs 750


If my total long term capital gain across all instruments is less than Rs 1lac, I don't pay any tax. Else I pay 10% of the gains exceeding 1Lac.

So my tax in this case will be between zero and Rs750. 


My nett will be between Rs 56750 and Rs 57500. And this is still less than Rs 58628 which I would have had if I had sold the scheme and repurchased and incurred TWO exit loads and TWO STCG @15%.


It may make sense to sell and repurchase at a much lower NAV. Note a lot depends on the difference between the NAV that I first redeemed and the NAV I repurchased at. If this spread was much less than Rs 10 (=90-80), this tactic wouldn't make sense.


What we have with this tactic is just a peace of mind that we have got out of a falling market. And if in fact we re-enter the market at a sufficiently lower NAV we stand to make a little extra money in the bargain. This is counter to the strategy of holding on for the long term.


Note also that the two STCG will result in tax cash outflow earlier. 


Now let's make it a little more abstract.

Assuming that the first redemption was at NAV of x (=90)


And let's repeat the same calculations.


Proceeds from 1st sale

495x - (495x-35000)*.15

=420.75x+5250


New number of units

(420.75x+5250)/80


2nd redemption value

(420.75x+5250)/80*.99*115

=(420.75+5250)*1.423

=598.78x+7471


2nd STCG

(598.78x+7471)-(420.75x+5250)

=178.03x+2221


2nd STCG tax

=(178.03x+2221)*.15

=26.7x+333


Nett after 2nd redemption

=(598.78x+7471)-(26.7x+333)

= 572x+7138


Nett after LT redemption

= 500*115=57500


At what NAV are the two nett equal?

572x+7138=57500

X=88


So long as x> 88, double redemption gives more.


The question that remains is how is this value of x dependent on the other three NAV (70, 80 and 115).

Let's assume a, b, c are the three NAV, respectively.

Proceeds from 1st sale

495x - (495x-500*a)*.15

=420.75x+5250

=420.75x+75a


New number of units

(420.75x+5250)/b

=420.75x/b+75a/b


2nd redemption value before tax

(420.75x+5250)/80*.99*115

=(420.75+5250)*1.423

=598.78x+7471

=(420.75x/b+75a/b)*0.99*c

=416.5cx/b+74.25ac/b


2nd STCG

(598.78x+7471)-(420.75x+5250)

=178.03x+2221


=(416.5cx/b+74.25ac/b) -

(420.75x+75a)

=(416.5c/b-420.75)x+(74.25c/b-75)a


2nd STCG tax

=(178.03x+2221)*.15

=26.7x+333

=((416.5c/b-420.75)x+(74.25c/b-75)a)*.15

=(62.5c/b-63)x+(11.14c/b-11.25)a


Nett after 2nd redemption

=(598.78x+7471)-(26.7x+333)

= 572x+7138

416.5cx/b+74.25ac/b - ((62.5c/b-63)x+(11.14c/b-11.25)a)

=(354c/b+63)x+(63.11c/b+11.25)a



Nett after LT redemption

= 500*c=57500


At what NAV are the two nett equal?

572x+7138=57500

X=88


So long as x> 88, double redemption gives more.


(354c/b+63)x+(63.11c/b+11.25)a > 500c




X> (500c - (63.11c/b+11.25)a) / (354c/b+63)



(57500-7138) /571.9

=50362/571.9

=88


In the above equation, x is higher (desirable) as c/b becomes lower and as a is lower.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1oIC6BHc1h7CJZ4qmKIPJ0uvBr2DyFe85ZXQMg257skk/edit?usp=drivesdk





Friday, July 9, 2021

Trump's Character - My Take

Barring few people most have a drive to succeed or what I call "survive" the way animals do. Animals have a no holds barred (no rules, anything goes) survival mechanism. Actually animals do follow rules. But for the sake of putting my thoughts together i call the "no holds barred" behaviour "survival Instinct".

Incidentally humans do have conscience and morality though the degree varies from person to person. You have a king Harishchandra and you have a Trump.


Trump is a person who has little conscience, his behavior is largely defined by survival Instinct. Born to a wealthy father he learnt that survival at any cost was the way in life. He has lived that way in every aspect of his life. Including finally claiming that he won the election by a huge margin. It's difficult to think of any depravity that he won't indulge in.


It's this behavior of his that alternately fascinates me and disgusts me.


Here is an article that shows his character. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-organization-investigation-property-values-vance-james/2021/11/19/78c15850-4706-11ec-95dc-5f2a96e00fa3_story.html


Here is another article around Jun 17 or 18, 2022. Hence, Mike Pence: Quote from it: "Mike Pence didn’t have the courage to do what should have been done to protect our Country and our Constitution, giving States a chance to certify a corrected set of facts, not the fraudulent or inaccurate ones which they were asked to previously certify,” Trump tweeted. “USA demands the truth!” 

Here is the interesting thing about Trump. He believed firmly that he won the election. And hence any data that indicated otherwise was fraudulent or inaccurate. This is a core trait of Trump. What he felt was the truth. 


From https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/0408ca2e-19a7-11ed-b4a0-f11f082a3a3c?shareToken=b0d09ffe1f82cbd86d7542971bec975d


From the above article. This is one major difference between US and UK. The question of intention. Trump gets away with every crime because American system requires that it be proved beyond reasonable doubt that he had the intention. A second issue with the American way is their predilection in thinking that if something were done in broad daylight there cannot be a nefarious intention. Trump does everything visibly and gets away


I get a thought. We often say that the enemy of our enemy is our friend. This paradigm is what makes him win. People hate something and Trump also claims to hate those things. And hence people see him as the enemy of an enemy and stand by him  


Shown below is Trump's response to questions about his involvement in Jan 6th events. 


And my comments about this: 

Of course the wolf's rendition of the encounter with red riding hood was a cartoon. And meant as a joke


Trump's recollection of Jan 6th and blaming tech companies for the issue.. is no different from the wolf's recollection. Except that in the case of Trump, he (his spokesman) is very serious.

Idiotic things said in jest are funny. When they are said in seriousness it's ugly.



Trump is a narcissist. He can comfortably arrogate to himself non existent qualities. He can lie through his teeth and expect people to accept it even if they didn't think it was true. He creates an alternative version of reality that he believes in. 


For example, His assets would be inflated if he needed money (for example while borrowing from a bank) and shown to be substantially low if he had to pay money (while filing his taxes).


There was no such thing as truth in his mind. His claims are usually preposterous.


Additional reading:

Saturday, May 1, 2021

People In Glass Houses

 


""Oxygen plants are essential. It is irresponsible not to have them," the bench said." - India Today: Batra Hospital runs out of oxygen, 8 patients die before Delhi govt rushes supply."

https://www.indiatoday.in/cities/delhi/story/batra-hospital-runs-out-of-oxygen-8-covid-patients-die-1796959-2021-05-01


Of late, high courts and supreme court have been castigating various entities like the election commission (for allowing political rallies during the pandemic), Delhi administration and Central Government for having Oxygen shortage. 

(https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/coronavirus-lets-try-and-not-be-a-cry-baby-centre-to-delhi-on-oxygen-crisis-amid-covid-19-2421034)


What surprises is me the performance of the courts themselves. The number of cases pending and the rate of disposal of cases (I am not talking about the correctness of judgments) leaves a lot to be desired. Couple of my friends have filed divorce cases and these are running for more than a year and these are cases where the wife hasn't asked for alimony, child support. I attended one virtual court hearing where the judge gave new dates for EACH case because she was at home and no paperwork was available with her lordship. 


Just great.


Shouldn't the courts fix their own problems first.


Additional reading 

https://www.bloombergquint.com/coronavirus-outbreak/dont-clamp-down-on-citizen-voices-justice-chandrachud-warns-states





Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Covid Deaths In India

We have been hearing about crematoriums running all day long, burial grounds running out of space as we are almost touching 3000 corona deaths per day.


I looked up the normal death statistics in India. 



That's about 7.3 deaths per year per thousand population. With a population of about 135 crores (1350 million) our annual deaths should be about (7.3 / 1000) * (1350 * 1000000) = 9,855,000.


If we convert it to a per day basis, it is 9855000/ 365 = 27000.


That means that India's death rate normally is about 27000 per day. Remember that India's covid deaths are about 3000 per day (at the time of writing).


Covid deaths are just about 10% of the normal deaths. How come our crematoriums and burial grounds are overflowing with just 10% extra deaths?


If we consider Delhi with a population of 20 million, the daily deaths in the city normally would be (7.3/1000*20,000,000)/365 = 400. 

If we assume that the daily Covid deaths in cities in India are proportional to the population of the cities then covid deaths in Delhi should be about 10% of the normal deaths in Delhi and hence should be about 40. Is this number anywhere close to reality?


Read this:

https://www.ndtv.com/delhi-news/delhi-coronavirus-deaths-over-1-000-covid-deaths-missing-in-delhi-data-reveal-civic-records-2422628 - enlightening.





What gives?


A friend disagreed. This is what he had to say:

I do not disagree with this analysis and I am sure there are codifying errors that skew the numbers but the only angle I feel is not to be concluded as siva is saying... that the numbers are being manipulated with intent to do so ..for if that is the case then we need not see death rate go up from 150 a day on an averages to 3500 a day on an average.....


Also logistics wise in a normal death there will be. T+1 time window of the body reaching crematorium....and people will wait either for an overseas relative to come or even to get a slot in a crematorium of choice ....the 15 percent surge is now perhaps coming in like an adrenaline surge as bodies are being instantly disposed..causing the overload on the ecosystem....


Cruel scenes sans cruel intent in governance is my only submission....


Additional reading:

Wednesday, July 29, 2020

Tracking And Estimating Covid-19 Cases In India

I created this spreadsheet:

I tracked total CUMULATIVE cases and deaths in India from Apr 21, 2020. The numbers were fairly low on this date - about 20,000 cases and 600 deaths total. 

The cases and deaths data for each date have been taken taken from 
https://www.covid19india.org/

As of Jul 29, 2020 there are about 1.5 million cases (including recovered cases and deaths) and 34,000 deaths.

The cases are currently doubling in 20 days while deaths are doubling at a slower pace: at 28 days.

The cases are increasing at about 3.5%/day while deaths are increasing at 2.4% / day. At the current rate, India will have about 41 million cases and 323,000 deaths by end of October 2020.

Note:

  1. I have assumed that cases and deaths increase at the SAME rate to October as they are now.
  2. Data till current date are actuals, while data for future dates (colored rows) are estimates.

Monday, June 29, 2020

Is Corona Serious?

I was discussing with a friend how little control I have now over things compared to say a year back - all because of Corona. 

She strongly disagreed with me. She said my belief that I had control earlier over my life was just an illusion. That I could just as well had met with an accident last year and lost my life. 

That all the data of probability of losing one's life last year being negligible would make no sense to the person who did lose their life last year. 

This was, hmm, quite a different way of looking at things. And I wasn't comfortable with her way of putting things. 

I couldn't exactly tell her that she was talking through her hat because she is well educated, has a sweet voice, a very pleasant accent, very touchy and anyways doesn't wear a hat. 

That didn't stop me from brooding on what she said. So I consulted the death statistics in India from 

The death rate is 7.3 per thousand population which is less than 1% of the population. 

And assuming India's population to be 130 crores (1300 million), the deaths in India in 4 months would be 1300*(4/12)*(7.3/1000) = 3 million  approx.

As of today, Corona deaths have amounted to 16,000 which is half a percent of the usual number of deaths in 4 months (Mar, Apr, May, Jun 29, 2020) in India. [3 million above]]

Less than half a percent. So, what are we really afraid of? Yeah, sure we may lose many 3 times that or 5 times that in the next 4 months. That's still 2 to 3% of the usual number of deaths. 

Was my friend right, after all? She can't be. She can barely count beyond single digits. Damn..

Friday, March 27, 2020

Coronavirus Statistics


The image below shows the stats of currently affected people worldwide split by condition - mild (95%) or serious (5%).








Bottom of the image shows the recovery to fatality ratio which is currently at 84:16. Meaning, out of 100 corona affected persons worldwide, 16 died and rest recovered. Fatality rate is 16% now. Few days back it was 14% and has increased to 16%.

Let us come to an interesting thing. The total affected patients as of now is 392k (392,527 see top of image). How many of this 392k will recover?

The ones that have a mild condition? If the virus kills at the current rate then the fatality world be 16% of 392k. The stats show that only 5% are critical. 
Assuming all those who are critical will die, where do the balance fatality of 11% (16%-5%) come from? 
This will come from those whose condition is currently mild. 

So we are looking at a fatality rate that is 16% of all affected people and the rate seems to be rising. We are also looking at good number of mildly affected patients might die.

How will the end game will play out (fatality becomes zero)?


Thursday, January 9, 2020

Emotional Expression Is Sexy

A friend of mine, who is a tireless worker with high energy, has a problem with her foot nowadays. She currently howls in pain when in private. 

Yesterday her boss asked her to take up some official work during the forthcoming Pongal holidays. My friend declined because she had made prior plans and was going out of town. The boss, another lady, was irritated and asked my friend why my friend had not informed her, the boss, of travel plans during the holidays. My friend was nonplussed. Was my friend required to inform her boss in advance of her personal plans during holidays? Did the company she worked for have primary lien on her time during holidays?

My friend told her boss that even if she wasn't going out of town, she couldn't have helped the boss out because of her recent severe foot problem. The boss explained that my friend had better get used to working with problems because everyone else in the company, including the boss, was already working with several problems in their lives.

Now comes the interesting analysis.
My friend puts in more work and helps out co-workers more than any other employee in that company. It's just that in this case she is in such pain that she cannot do any more work. Her pain tolerance is very high and she rarely complains. She works at office and at home where they have no maid, cook and no other support (in laws for example).

With the above background in mind which even her boss knew, we come to understand how the boss thinks.

Any work done without pain doesn't count. Since my friend never expressed any pain, her contribution didn't count for much. Other employees' contribution counted to the extent of pain expressed by those employees.

This is the realm of a feeler. Tangible contribution is subservient to pain expressed. Meaning you get more rewards for doing x work with pain than doing 2x work with no pain. 

Ain't that rich? Welcome to the world of women (like my friend's boss).

Additional reading 
https://goodmenproject.com/featured-content/mans-emotional-intelligence-new-sexy-jrmk/

Monday, December 30, 2019

Ashkenazi Jews And Sensitivity


The purpose of analysis and research is to come out with formulas that can be applied with accuracy elsewhere too. So long as the formulas pertain to things like relativity or gravity there seems to be no problem. The moment we mention a formula that pertains to people (whether Ashkenazi Jews or Women or Indians or blondes...) we seem to face a problem. We are told that we are racist, judgmental. Instances like the ex Dean of Harvard or the Google employee, (both of whom mentioned that women were generally not as fit as men for STEM discipline and both of whom had to leave their institutions) come to mind. Instead of looking at whether the data and conclusion are accurate we tend to look at whether the conclusion affects the sensitivities of people. The same thing happened with Darwin. His conclusion affected the sensibilities of religious people. 

Sensitivity to sentiments seems to come in the way of science and analysis.

If research has to be constantly mindful of how its conclusions may affect the sentiments of certain sections of the population we may as well start taking long strides forward to the 10th century.

Can emotions be conducive to understanding truth (formulas)?

Additional reading

  1. The Jews and American Progress : Unbelievable! Letters to the editor re: the original article.
  2. https://vbala99.blogspot.com/2015/09/intelligence-variation-with-religion.html

Sunday, December 29, 2019

Recipe For Depression, CEO And Mischief

When one has a lot of emotions, and very little energy, one can go into depression because they cannot do much and things aren't happy.

People with a lot of emotions and some energy and lot of skills do something useful. They become CEO's of benign (or at times malefic) enterprises.

People with a lot of emotions and some energy and less skills turn  into mischief.

Wednesday, December 25, 2019

My Husband - Answer To The Puzzle

I had earlier written about something that puzzled me https://vbala99.blogspot.com/2019/01/my-husband.html

Why do wives and daughters think so differently about their husbands and fathers respectively, as human beings, so differently?

I finally figured out the answer.
Daughters love their fathers because they take care of their daughters, protect them and love them.
BUT because they love their fathers they ALSO think their fathers are great human beings (when they are not really great human beings). This is a mistake daughters make.

Wives dislike their husbands because they are too silly, insensitive, inattentive, unreliable etc BUT because they hate their husbands they ALSO think their husbands are awful human beings (when they are not really awful human beings). This is a mistake wives make.

Both daughters and wives exaggerate the nature of their fathers / husbands as human beings. This is a human tendency. When we like someone, we attend to think they are good at everything. And VICE VERSA.

Most sons think that their mothers are nice while most husbands think that their wives could do with some improvement. The difference in perception is not as much as in the case of daughters and wives, I think.

Men tend not to think too much about relationships while women focus primarily on them and exaggerate (in a benign way or malignant way depending on the object being evaluated) and hence create a whole lot of confusion in people like me. 

It took me almost a year to figure this one out.

Saturday, December 21, 2019

Rekha And Munna

I was discussing with a friend the film characters of Rekha in Khubsoorat and of Sanjay Dutt in Munna Bhai MBBS. After watching both the movies (I watched the 2nd one 2 decades after watching the first one), my initial reaction towards both the characters was positive and I felt more negative about Rekha's (future) mother in law in the movie and about Sanjay Dutt's (future) father in law in Munna Bhai.

Both the parents in law were J (as in MBTI) characters, rigid, insisting that things only be done one way, seemed as though they had piles, their lives full of Must, Should etc. Rekha and Munna, on the other hand, were P (as in MBTI) cheerful, flexible, nice to be with be, easygoing etc. Rekha was seen by her MIL as a person not disciplined enough and hence unfit to be her daughter in law. Munna was seen by his father in law as a person who was totally unfit to be his son in law because Munna was a gangster and uneducated unlike the father in law and the heroine who were both doctors. 

And the way Rekha took care of Ashok Kumar, her future father in law, when he had a heart attack and when she was alone with him and the way Munna created happiness in the patients (Jimmy Shergill) and brought life back to the Bengali person in coma (Anand) seemed to belie the poor opinions of their respective parents in law.

When we finished watching the movie we were left with the belief that Rekha and Munna were dependable and good people, perhaps much better than their respective uptight parents in law.

Now here comes the interesting part. 

Think back to the movie characters Rekha and Munna. Do we want our spouses or friends or daughter/son in law to be available in those rate instances when there is a crisis and generally unavailable most of the time for doing anything useful? Do we need Munna's "jaadu ki jhappi" more than his father in law's medical skills? Are we right in assuming that J people are unavailable or incapable of handling emergencies?
Sure I cannot imagine Boman Irani (Munna's FIL) solving problems through EQ. Has EQ become so much important than hard skills? Where will mankind be if all people had high EQ and no hard skills (or hard skills that only rarely emerged as in the case of Rekha)? 


I realized that I have a tendency to get conned by elegant communication as in the case of the two movies mentioned above. I need to be more careful. If I were an elderly lady lying in my death bed, would I be comfortable leaving my family in the hands of a Rekha? Or would I prefer someone like her MIL or like Mrs Soumitra in Bela Sheshe?

Is this the kind of of high EQ and mostly no hard skills or rarely exhibited hard skills that I should be clapping or clamoring for? How did we start allowing EQ to triumph discipline and dependability?

Note:
Indirectly I am equating P with EQ and J with its absence. 

Tuesday, December 17, 2019

I Am Grateful To You

This is the search results for the expression FEELING GRATEFUL.


We can see from the links how important it is to feel grateful. Being grateful or thankful to nature or to individuals is so nice. 

Recently when I heard a person tell another that she was grateful to the guy for all that he had done for her involuntarily my blood boiled. There were strong negative vibes in me.

I probed my feelings. And this is what my left brain came up with.

When we say we are grateful or thankful to a person for all that they have done for us we implicitly deny any indebtedness to them. The profound "thank you" squares all the debt or things that we received from another person. What we then feel is that should the other person ever have a problem we would be favorably inclined to do something for them. Being indebted to them, on the other hand, means that we would do something for the other person not just being favorably inclined.

This is a crucial difference. The feeling of gratefulness is nice - it does beat being an ingrate any time. But feeling grateful really is a very shallow behavior compared to feeling indebted to that person. It's surprising how gracefully we have camouflaged the ugly shallow behavior in the guise of a beautiful one. 

What really gets my goat is the tendency for an sweet person to say to a benefactor "You have already done so much good for me and for others. I don't know how to thank you for all that you have done. But I need one more favor from you..."


Only a horrible person can repay favors taken with request for one more and package it with gratitude towards the benefactor. 


In summary, "I am grateful to you" is usually a way of saying "I am not indebted to you". Thank you empaths.

Recent example:
"Actor-turned-politician Urmila Matondkar posted pictures with the legend, saying, "You shaped me as an actor. You saw the talent in a girl from a middle-class family and introduced me to the silver screen. I'll never be able to pay back what you have done for me. Will Miss you #ShreeramLagoo" from https://m.economictimes.com/magazines/panache/eminent-theatre-and-film-actor-shriram-lagoo-91-dead/articleshow/72859320.cms

So nice.

Additional reading

Popular Posts

Featured Post

Oh, I Think I Was Raped

We have been hearing about the Cornell (University) 7 - the frat boys who gangraped a Jane Doe on Oct 19, 2024.  There have been 2 points o...